Murray Chass of the New York Times leads a story on the Sports Page with this bromide:
Alcohol last week killed one more major league baseball player than steroids ever have.
If you didn't get it the first time, he repeats:
I repeat: Alcohol last week killed one more baseball player than steroids ever have.
This story in the big paper in the Big Apple, doesn't get it Big Time. I repeat, the Times spit the bit.
Alcohol constitutes a major public health problem. Alcohol use, abuse, tolerance, withdrawal, and delirium all contribute to major morbidity and mortality. Alcohol inebriation clearly causes fatal results if combined with driving, or boating, or swimming, or other activities requiring mental alertness. Long term alcohol use causes psychosis, dementia, depression, hormonal problems, cardiac hypertrophy, liver cirrhosis, diabetes, gastritis, fetal alcohol syndrome, and other major problems I haven't mentioned such as job loss, marital strife and on.
Last time any scientist looked, steroid use and abuse can cause emotional changes, psychosis, depression, hormonal problems, cardiac hypertrophy, liver damage, tumors, diabetes, possible fetal defects, azospermia, acne, aggression, and crime.
So why would an author trash one public health campaign to bitch complain about MLB not doing enough about another public health issue and public fraud investigation? Someone explain the logic. Please.
More from the Times:
Yet Major League Baseball and George J. Mitchell
and Congress and the steroids zealots are in a tizzy over the use of
performance-enhancing substances in baseball. At least Mitchell is
being paid to care about them, but he is in such a frenzy to get to the
core of steroid use that he wants to run roughshod over federal and
state laws barring an employer’s release of an employee’s medical
records.
When baseball has addressed the issue of drugs of abuse
and performance enhancement, it has always ignored alcohol. Alcohol,
after all, is legal for most players of major league age...
But
if players who use steroids serve as poor role models for children, so
do players who drive drunk and kill themselves...
This and the rest that follows simply is silly. Inane.
The morbidity and mortality from booze, and tobacco (how did that get into this discussion?) are significant. Does that mean MLB is all wrong for initiating an investigation into steroid and PED use?
Take anabolic steroids. A person does not inject some Deca then go out and drive inebriated. However, chronic use of 'roids makes one more aggressive. Ask several experts who are testifying in steroid-tainted murder trials, including steroid expert Harrison Pope. You don't have the immediate dulling of cognition, however the citizen in Florida shot by a juiced-up aggressive cop is every bit as dead as the next corpse.
Alcohol affects your brain. Steroids affect your brain. My friend at a New York research center will likely demonstrate some very interesting brain blood flow studies in the future looking at anabolic steroids affecting brain perfusion.
Alcohol causes cardiac problems. Steroids are suspected of causing cardiac problems too (although HGH is the biggie in this category).
Alcohol attacks the liver. Steroids attack the liver.
Alcohol can decrease testicular production of testosterone. Steroids can decrease the testicular output of testosterone.
Anything alcohol can do, steroids can do better...
Yeah, but alcohol causes fetal alcohol syndrome. Ask the German female swimmers if anabolic steroids caused the multiple birth defects seen in their children...then watch them weep.
In short, the use of anabolic steroids causes significant, if delayed, public health problems. Google 'dead pro wrestler and anabolic steroids'. There are 281,00 hits. Not trivial.
Clearly alcohol presents a much more prevalent public health problem than anabolic steroids. That does not mean the investigation into juice should be dismantled leaving all the funds for alcohol education. Both are important public health issues.
That was the apples and apples, the public health aspect of the issue.
Now the apples and oranges: anabolic steroid use is sports-fraud, and drug-cheating. Alcohol use is generally more recreational use. If we discuss the morbidity and mortality from recreational drug use, then alcohol dominates a large part of the discussion; anabolic steroids do not sit at that discussion. However, steroids partake of the discussion concerning morbidity and mortality of American drugs of abuse, and of America sports fraud. Steroids and PEDs simply require more time to produce deleterious results. The sinister deleterious health consequences of PEDs sneak up on a person, which is difficult for the instant gratification or instance annihilation people to understand
Make no mistake using simple-minded short term thinking; there are significant morbidity and mortality issues when discussing the PEDs. We don't need to rob Peter to pay Paul. We need to understand fully the issues behind any contemporary drug problem. Even if those issues demand serious thinking.
Major League Baseball has made television commercials warning
against the dangers of steroids, and dangerous though they may be for
possible future ill effects, no baseball player is known to have died
from using them. Ken Caminiti admitted using steroids, but he died at
the age of 41 from a drug overdose that included cocaine but not
steroids.
Putting
steroids in perspective, since the Balco investigation began four years
ago, 1.6 million people have died from smoking-related causes (400,000
a year, the United States surgeon general says) and about 150,000
(nearly half in traffic accidents) have died from alcohol-related
causes.
How comforting it is to know that some people care more
about baseball’s career home run record than the lives of hundreds of
thousands of human beings.
How discomforting to know the New York Times makes no sense on this issue.
Recent Comments